Yoon Seok-yeol's diplomatic remarks: Court misjudges MBC's 'Biden misinformation' ruling due to 'diplomatic ignorance'
The court showed a misjudgment by arbitrarily interpreting President Yoon Seok-yeol's overseas diplomatic remarks and creating the basis for MBC's ruling on 'Biden misinformation.'
Immediately after the ROK-US summit meeting on MBC in New York, the court said it was 'impossible to judge' the key issues in President Yoon Seok-yeol's outspoken remarks and ruled that they were 'not Biden's remarks' on the basis that the US's 'budget approval' was 'natural' to Korea. .
The Western District Court ruling said, “It is natural to assume that President Yoon Seok-yeol made remarks in this case to the National Assembly of the Republic of Korea for the above purpose,” and “It cannot be said that President Yoon Seok-yeol used profanity and profanity toward the U.S. Congress and Biden.” 12 The ruling was made.
The ruling presented the fundamental judgment as a 'presumption', saying, "It is reasonable to believe that it has not been clearly revealed whether President Yoon Seok-yeol said 'Biden is' or 'If you fly,'" even though the person making the statement was a living, real person, and presented the facts of the recorded broadcast. was avoided, and the ruling showed a misjudgment by concluding that 'interpretation is natural' regarding field recordings.
The climate conference held in a New York hotel was hosted by the White House, President Yoon was an attendee, and it was an error for the court to rule that the conference was a matter under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs regarding the diplomatic official action of briefly meeting Biden and the provocative remarks made in the U.S.-hosted conference hall upon exiting the conference.
President Yoon's diplomacy was packaged as a 'diplomatic act' on the condition that he make a donation and meet Biden briefly, and as a participant rather than a conference organizer, the Korean Ministry of Foreign Affairs said that 'attendance at the conference' and 'donation to the climate conference' were under its jurisdiction, and leaving the conference room was the responsibility of the White House. and the New York Police Department.
President Yoon was not granted diplomatic rights, such as the right to speak or vote, at the climate conference that day.
The ruling said, "For South Korea to contribute $100 million to the Global Fund, the consent of the National Assembly is essential, but at the time, the opposition party held the majority of the seats in the National Assembly, and the ruling party was in opposition," based on the judgment that "President Yoon Seok-yeol made the 7th Global Fund financial pledge." It was ruled that the meeting was conducted in the process of leaving the event venue after the meeting, and that the above meeting was a matter under the jurisdiction of the plaintiff (Ministry of Foreign Affairs).
President Yoon attempted to hold a summit meeting with US President Biden in New York on this day, but it did not take place. As President Yoon attended the 'Global Fund Financial Pledge Meeting' hosted by Biden, he was given a 'meeting in person' for 43 seconds and was 'ignored and downgraded'. Although it is easy for anyone to see through diplomatic judgment that dissatisfaction with the ‘established status’ arises, the court excluded this basic relationship and changed the mutual relationship to ‘President Yoon and the National Assembly of Korea’.
President Yoon's remarks were at the core of the 'failure to approve Congress', which holds the U.S. budget, and in particular, the remarks on this day were made right after President Yoon's speech at the United Nations General Assembly on 'removing countries that threaten freedom', which is the ideology of the U.S. Republican Party, in November, when the political fate of Biden's Democratic Party is at stake. In the congressional election, the Democratic Party emerged from the political slogans 'Inflation Reduction Act' and 'Climate Agreement' and 'Republican dominance' As a result of the election to take control of Congress, 'climate budget hit' was highlighted as a basic element in the United States.
In fact, President Yoon's remarks were made in November, when the White House and the Biden system, which were pushed out of the budgetary power in the US Republican-dominated Congress, suffered the crisis of 'federal government bankruptcy,' The remarks at the ‘Financial Contribution Conference’ were directly related to the American political crisis.
The Western District Court's ruling said, "In order for the Republic of Korea to contribute $100 million to the Global Fund, the consent of the National Assembly is essential, but at the time, the opposition party held a majority of the seats in the National Assembly. "If this is not done, there is sufficient concern that trust in the Republic of Korea in the international community may decline. Therefore, it is natural to assume that President Yoon Seok-yeol made remarks in this case to the National Assembly of the Republic of Korea with the above purpose in mind," the New York ruling ruled. It was completely separated from the international situation at the time. President Yoon visited Foreign Minister Park Jin and told him immediately after contacting Biden with his 'approval' statement about the 'inflation reduction law mistake', and if the Republican Party gains the upper hand with Korean support in the November US election, the President It appears to be aimed at the rejection of the U.S. Congress, which has the power to approve the treaty.
There is almost no possibility that President Yoon, a lawyer, cannot distinguish between the United States’ ‘budget approval rights’ and Korea’s ‘executive budget passage procedures.’
The court judges collectively boasted in their ruling that the ‘Korean National Assembly budget approval’ was “natural.”
In Korea, both the government and the media and political parties used the term ‘pass’ in the supplementary budget, and the People Power Party spokesperson officially expressed it as ‘pass’ in the last supplementary budget request announcement.
In the United States, the budget authority lies with Congress, and the White House creates a budget plan and asks Congress for approval, and Congress exercises all authority, including revisions and cuts, through deliberation by the Congressional Budget Office. It is under the jurisdiction of Congress.
The U.S. President has the ‘blanket veto’ on the approved budget and does not have the right to make partial amendments, so he uses ‘approval’.
In Korea, the executive branch holds the budgetary authority and requests the National Assembly to pass the bill. The ruling and opposition parties go through the process of passing an agreement after partial revision, and the executive branch executes the bill in bulk, so the term ‘approval’ was never used.
President Yoon's 'approval' statement was made by visiting Foreign Minister Park Jin immediately after contacting Biden about the 'mistake of the inflation reduction law' and speaking to him. He expressed his dissatisfaction with Minister Park about being treated poorly by standing for 43 seconds at the summit and said, 'Biden of the United States. It can be judged to be more 'natural' that the Democratic Party assumed the US election in November.
President Yoon has publicly shared the U.S. Republican Party's hard-line conservative strategy of 'spreading liberalism', and has the position and information to know well that the U.S. Congress, which has the power to approve the president's treaty, will reject the president's treaty approval if the Republican Party gains the upper hand in the U.S. midterm elections due to support from Korea. The Republican Party won the November election with a majority.
Immediately after taking office, Democratic President Biden officially apologized for the Republican Trump administration's surprise withdrawal from the Paris Agreement in 2017 in a speech at the United Kingdom's Conference of the Parties (COP26) to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change in February 2021.
The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change was evaluated as an achievement achieved by the Democratic Party's Obama administration, and was suddenly withdrawn and neutralized immediately after Republican President Trump took office, becoming the core of the election showdown between the Republican and Democratic parties.
President Biden and President Yoon's contribution of US$6 billion at the 'Financial Fund Meeting' right before the shock in New York remarks on this day is a major political check for the Republican Party, which will become the majority party with the approval of the US Congress.
The contribution that President Yoon mentioned on this day was ‘$100 million over three years,’ and it was not an issue that conflicted with the National Assembly as Korea had contributed $25 million over the previous three years.
The ‘2023 budget plan’ has a budget of 276.7 billion won for international fund project contributions, which is a surge of more than 100 billion won compared to 2022 year and is more than the $100 million that the president said.
The government has already set aside 9.6 billion won for the 'Global Fund vaccine development, distribution, and disease eradication activities' appropriated by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in the 2023 budget, and there has been no case in which National Assembly deliberation or international contributions have been reduced.
As for President Yoon's profanity scandal in the United States, as judged by experts, the reason why President Yoon used the term 'approval' takes precedence over security, and the direct explanation of the person concerned takes precedence over the court's decision on the 'Biden, if you blow it' recording.
At the time of President Yoon's remarks, Korean media outlets were competing to report on the 'Republican advantage' in the U.S. midterm elections in November, attempting to expand Korea's conservatism by supporting the Republican Party. President Yoon himself is a hard-line conservative and has maintained a strategic partnership with the Heritage Foundation, a supporter of the Republican Party. there was.
On June 5, 1991, when Roh Tae-woo and Gorbachev were at the San Francisco Hotel, the venue for the Korea-Soviet summit, the moment they boarded the elevator to move to the conference room, Korean bodyguards and reporters flocked in and an ashtray was knocked over, creating a commotion. A San Francisco police officer pulled out a pistol and said, "This is my business." The incident that calmed the situation by shouting, "was reported in the American media at the time.
<6th Republic Media Manipulation, 1991> < Budget authority Congress ‘approves in the U.S.’ Administration ‘passes in Korea’ Republican Party ‘supports’, September 24, 2022> See